While everyone was busy discussing TiVo’s new pricing scheme yesterday, I was downtown at the US Court of Appeals researching TiVo v EchoStar. For whatever reason, many documents from this Federal Circuit court haven’t made it online — Fortunately, the building is just a short subway ride away and photocopies are only 15 cents a page. Without seeing the documents we’ve speculated on the rationale behind the extension/delay, but now we’re a little more informed. EchoStar justifies their 10/16 motion for an extension due to several appeals that should be combined, outstanding motions in district court must be ruled on, and that their legal team is very busy with other cases. TiVo’s reply on 10/19 argues damages will continue during an extension and that the schedules of Echostar’s lawyers are irrelevant.
I’ve passed these documents on to my secret agent for a more thorough analysis and expect I’ll be picking up soon-to-be released documents within in the next week. When will it end!? One ZNF reader theorizes, “I’ve mapped out the major milestones in the RIM lawsuit as signposts to the TIVo one. If that’s any indication, it won’t be resolved until 2008… and settlement will be at a much higher dollar amount.” Stay tuned…