It looks like TiVo, Netflix and Blockbuster will be packing their bags for Massachusetts, after they won the first of many legal scrimmages in their patent defense against Lycos. Lycos has asserted that all three companies have violated patents they own, on âinformation filtering technology.â? The two patents that are at the heart of the case are related to the recommendation services that the companies provide.
After Lycos filed their lawsuit against the trio, ChoiceStream (the company that created Blockbusterâs suggestion service) filed a separate lawsuit, to have the patents thrown out.
In their lawsuit against Lycos, they argue that the patents are invalid because of obviousness and prior art. Because Choicestream filed their own lawsuit in the Massachusettsâ court system, TiVo, Netflix and Blockbuster sought to have their case transferred there as well. Iâm not familiar enough with the legal subtleties to know why Lycos originally opposed the motion, but with Lycosâ headquarters in MA, the judge found the request reasonable enough and granted the motion.
While this development in the case, is only a minor footnote in the larger dispute, the legal filing did contain more background on the case, as well as a few interesting side details.
It turns out that Choicestream may actually end up playing a pretty important role in how this gets resolved. In the legal filing the judge writes,
ChoiceStream has employees in Massachusetts who possess information relevant to this action, and Lycos has indicated that it âmay need to take some discovery from ChoiceStream.’
I havenât read ChoiceStreams lawsuit against Lycos yet, but it wouldnât surprise me if they did end up owning some prior art. A year ago, they filed an application for their own recommendation patent, so it will be interesting to see what ends up coming out at trial.
It also appears MITâs Media Lab could be called to give testimony. Part of their research was used to reject some of the original claims on one of Lycosâ patents. Believe it or not, theyâve actually been publishing research on âinformation filteringâ? since the late 80âs.
While it appears that this case is heading for trial, there is always the possibility of a settlement. Even though Lycos filed their lawsuit on Jan. 3, they didnât actually serve TiVo, Netflix or Blockbuster until April 30th because they were engaged in âsettlement discussionsâ? with the companies. Since they now appear to be squabbling over who gets home court advantage, those talks have likely cooled off, but it wouldnât surprise me to see either side at the bargaining table, especially if things start to look bad for them.
Davis Freeberg is a technology enthusiast living in the Bay Area. He enjoys writing about movies, music, and the impact that digital technology is having on traditional media. You can read more of his musings at www.davisfreeberg.com. Davis owns shares of TiVo and Netflix stock.